September 14th, 2007 at 5:51 pm

There’s another debate about ad-blocking software on browsers and what kind of legal ramifications it might have — all of which is silly and futile.  I don’t know what might come out of that debate from a legal point of view, but I can assure everyone one result I *am* certain of:

An increased awareness of ad-blocking software.

While its true that only a small proportion of web surfers actually use ad-blocking software, I’ll also bet that a small proportion of users *also* don’t really use plugins, different themes, or even Firefox (or a non MSIE browser).  

But you know what?  They might now.

And that’s the real sorry and absurd thing about this debate.  The code that exists to circumvent ads on websites exists publicly.  You can bet that people will happily add and change it to reflect any “advances” in ad-serving technology.  And you can bet that the ad-serving po-lice aren’t going to come after individual ad-blocking users.

The only thing the debate is going to do is fuel the awareness of such technologies and the uptake of such technologies — and once the cat’s out of the bag, you’ll never put it back in no matter how absurdly litigious you want to get.

Just ask the RIAA.

[as a post script, I'll assert that ad-blocking technologies are a very good thing: people that use ad-blocking will almost never click or pay attention to those ads anyway, AND they will force advertisers, marketers *and* webmasters to come up with alternative ways to monetize traffic that is actually palatable to said "traffic".  Yes, yes, I know, easier said than done, and no, PayPerPal doesn't work for everyone, so its an opportunity if nothing else :) ]

3 Responses to “The Recent Ad-Blocking Debate Is Absurd And Futile”

  1. Maggie Stone :

    One of the more interesting analyses of the Adblock Plus/ Firefox blocking controversy is that it is, in itself, simply a method of generating links and traffic.

  2. Mark Evans :

    Tony,
    You’re probably right. During some of my recent rants against AdBlock Plus, I deliberately didn’t provide the company’s URL so it wasn’t too easy for people to get to it.

  3. wait a second, you can legally force me to watch your ads? – by [muhammad.saleem] :

    [...] question of whether something can be done about firefox and ad-block plus, the honest truth is that all that is going to come from discussions of the plugin is increased exposure and greater user adoption to the point where advertisers are forced to [...]

Leave a Reply.

Please note the comments policy

Sep
14
2007
5:51 pm