Digg Controversy Explodes

by Tony Hung on September 7, 2006

Digg goes boom -- the controversy goes supernovaWell, I was going to do about how now is the best time for getting into GTD (watch for it … its still coming) — but the whole Digg controversy thing isn’t going away, so I’m going to stay with it until it does.

Having woke up this morning, there has been an utter explosion of news, commentary, and coverage over this most recent spate at Digg. Unlike ForeverGeek, Aliwood, or any other phenomena, the particular issue of the top 20 or 30 diggers ‘circle-digging’ each other (intentionally or no) seems to have really gone supernova, literally, over the course of less than 24h.

The Timeline

1. jesusphreak posts his article on his observation that FP posts seem to be dominated by the Top20

2. a firestorm of commentary erupts on Digg, with rumblings of group-marking all top20 submissions as “lame” or to be “buried”.
3. the original article is marked as innacurate, and gets Dugg into the stratosphere at the same time

4. the sheer volume of comments prompts Kevin Rose to issue an edict proclamation statement over how Digg will change its algorithm

5. top digger p9 leaves Digg amongst the implied accusation that he is gaming Digg.

6. news gets picked up by TechCrunch

7. coverage bursts into conflagatory orgy of commentary, news, finger wagging, and of course titles which play on the name “digg” (see below)

With the enormous amount of coverage TechCrunch gets on its own, I think it was the ‘tipping point’ to all the other major blogs / news sources picking it up.

So far the stories have hit:

4 comments

as i’m sure you can see my email address from your admin panel, i’d like to have a chat via email with you man, if that’s okay with you.

-TheAttacks

by Jeremiah on September 7, 2006 at 10:10 pm. #

Jeremiah, it would be a pleasure.
Check your email — I sent one off earlier in the evening.

Cheers
t @ dji

by Tony on September 8, 2006 at 1:29 am. #

[...] What Kevin Rose Could Learn from Jason Calacanis (Or, A Look at Why Digg’s PR Shockingly Bad) September 12th, 2006 at 11:14 am by Tony Earlier last week, there was a giant blowout of controversy over how the top / elite Digg users might have been manipulating (intentionally or no) the Digg promotion algorithm to get their stories promoted to the front page. I say “blowout” only because of the sort of blogospheric media coverage it got — as opposed to the “other” times controversies may or may not have happened. [...]

by Deep Jive Interests » What Kevin Rose Could Learn from Jason Calacanis (Or, A Look at Why Digg’s PR Shockingly Bad) on September 12, 2006 at 11:16 am. #

Leave your comment

Not published.

If you have one.

Powered by WP Hashcash